5 Mill Hill Road

Edgartown, MA, United States
USD $2,857 - $3,143 USD Nightly
Short Term Rentals
5 Beds
5 Baths
3500 sqft
Built 2015


Designed by noted architectural firm Hutker Architects, this modern interpretation of a classic farmhouse with pool and Carriage House, is sleekly set on three acres in a quiet Katama neighborhood.

The Main House features an open Great Room with Living, Dining, and Kitchen Areas. The stunning room features 16-foot vaulted ceilings with vintage beams and trusses, plus a fieldstone fireplace, and large windows with views over the surrounding meadows.

The state-of-the-art Chefs Kitchen features limestone counters, prep island/breakfast bar with quartz and oak counters, and commercial stainless appliances. The monochromatic grey and white color scheme from the Great Room is carried throughout the compound.

There are two first floor Master Bedrooms, both with deluxe ensuite baths. There is another Bedroom with en suite bath upstairs, plus the fourth Bedroom, and a full shared bath. All of the bathrooms are nicely outfitted with Restoration Hardware vanities and quartz counters.

There is a Media Room/Lounge on the lower level with media center, built-ins, sofa and chairs, plus half bath. There is a Sonos internet sound system throughout.

The Carriage House suite above the garage features an open design with vaulted ceiling and vintage beams.

There is sleek outdoor space as well, including a covered porch with outdoor fireplace off the Main House Great Room, and a large, heated 18 x 40-foot gunite pool and bluestone patio with lounging and dining areas.

The property is ideally located midway between South Beach and Edgartown Village, with the bike path and Katama General store nearby.

NOTE: Pool is heated to 81 degrees and included in the rent from June 24 thru September 3. Pool heat during the rest of June and September is an additional $250/week. Heat is $350/week in October



Bar, Cable TV, Ceiling Fan, Garden, Kitchenware, Large Kitchen Island, Media/Game Room, Pantry, Pool, Smart Home Technology, Vacuum System, Walk-In Closets, Wireless Internet.


Automatic Pool Cleaner, Blender, Built in Wine Cooler, Burglar Alarm, Ceiling Fans, Central Air Conditioning, Central Vacuum, Coffee Maker, Dishwasher, Gas Appliances, Grill, Ice Maker, Kitchen Island, Kitchen Sink, Microwave Oven, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel, Toaster, Washer & Dryer, Wine Cooler.

General Features

Fireplace, Heat, Non Smoking, Parking, Private.

Interior Features

Air Conditioning, Breakfast bar, Built-in Bookcases/Shelves, Carbon Monoxide Detector, Cathedral/Vaulted/Tray Ceiling, Central Vacuum, Entertainment Center, Floor to Ceiling Windows, Home Theater Equipment, Kitchen Island, Network/Internet Wired, Solid Wood Doors, Stereo System, Stone Counters, Two Story Ceilings, Walk-In Closet, Washer and dryer.


Family Room, Great Room, Guest House Separate, Inside Laundry, Kitchen/Dining Combo, Living/Dining Combo.

Exterior Features

Barbecue, Deck, Enclosed Porch(es), Exterior Lighting, Fireplace/Fire Pit, Large Open Gathering Space, Lawn Sprinkler, Outdoor Living Space, Outside Shower, Patio, Sunny Area(s), Swimming, Terrace, Thermal Windows/Doors, Under Ground Electric.

Exterior Finish

Cedar Siding.


Hardwood, Tile.


Off Street.


Pastoral View, Pasture View, Scenic View, Swimming Pool View, Trees.


Country Home, Island.

Short Term Rental Rates/Periods

July Rates
Jun 28 — Jul 26
August Rates
Jul 26 — Aug 22

Additional Resources


General Disclaimer

To the fullest extent permissible pursuant to applicable law, this web site and the materials are provided on an "as is" and "as available" basis. LuxuryRealEstate.com expressly disclaims all warranties of any kind, whether expressed, implied, or statutory including, but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and non-infringement. We do not warrant that this web site or the materials are completely error free, will operate without interruption, are compatible with all equipment and software configurations, free of viruses, errors, or other harmful components, or will otherwise meet your needs.